Zephyr Scale vs Azure Test Plans

From $10 per user/month (indicative, Atlassian Marketplace tiers)

From $52 per user/month (indicative)

Like Xray, priced per Jira user via the Marketplace. Zephyr Squad is a cheaper, lighter sibling product.

One of the more expensive per-user test management licences, but bundled into existing Azure DevOps agreements.

30-day trial.

Included exploratory testing extension is free; Test Plans itself requires a licence.

Widely used

SmartBear · since 2016

Established

Microsoft · since 2018

• Purpose-built case repository with parameterisation and shared steps that scale better than issue-based storage.
• Cross-project reporting for programme-level quality visibility.
• Version history on test cases, which matters for audit.

• Native traceability between work items, code, pipelines and tests.
• No extra vendor if you already run Azure DevOps.
• Solid exploratory testing capture through the browser extension.

• Two similarly named products (Squad and Scale) cause genuine purchasing confusion.
• Still bound to Jira's performance envelope.
• Per-Jira-user pricing again inflates cost for large organisations.

• Expensive per user compared to standalone alternatives.
• Weak outside the Microsoft ecosystem.
• Interface and reporting lag dedicated test management tools.

Larger Jira organisations with test libraries big enough that reuse matters.

Enterprises fully committed to Azure DevOps.